Can a Christmas carol offend the Immaculata?






The first time I heard the popular new carol “Mary, did you know?” sung by Cee Lo Green, I was struck by a sense of reverence at the depth of the mystery the song lays out. It became part of my Advent/Christmas playlist.   CeeLo Green – “Mary Did You Know” [Official Audio]

Recently a friend opined that they found the song offensive to Mary, since she, immaculately conceived and a well-versed daughter of Israel would of course have known all of these things… How rude to assume her ignorance….








Images courtesy of Pinterest


I reflected on that for a while, doing a little examination of conscience to see if I had been trivializing my blessed mother in some way, or negating some element of doctrine or dogma by enjoying this song.…

Instead what struck me was the way the song reveres the mysteries of faith with childlike wonder and discovery…  It’s like having my little child come up to me and ask, Mom, do you know how the mountains were created?  Do you know that the sun rises in the east and sets in the west?  Do you know the stars move in the sky? Did you know what the saints did?  Do you know how strong Dad is?  Do you know how smart my sister is?  Mom, did you know…?

Or what if a friend or acquaintance came up to you and started asking you if you knew how great your child was, and the amazing thigs he did…?  How could you be offended? Your heart would swell with love!

Would the Theotokos be offended by the fact that someone may not yet know the depth of the dogma of the Immaculate Conception, or was discovering the merits of her son with joy?… I can’t imagine it.  I CAN imagine her holding a child who was singing this song to her, and smiling lovingly, knowingly, as they explore the meaning of her Maternity.

Don’t feel guilty about enjoying this song. Christmas is the perfect time to gaze in awe and sing about Mary’s son.  Listen to it and ponder in your heart the mysteries it speaks about, knowing Mary is smiling at your childlike wonder. Even if she did know.


About Kerrie Rivard

Writer, communicator, Canadian living in the US, and mother of 6, Kerrie Rivard blogs to connect the dots between her never-boring life and the things God is doing in her soul. Her missionary passions include accompanying others as they discover and live in the love of Christ, being a second mom to a Chinese international student who lives with them, regularly stocking the house with snacks for the random number of teenagers who habitually show up in her kitchen, and learning from the wisdom of homeless people she meets on family missions in downtown Atlanta. If she had all the time in the world she would spend more of it in adoration before the blessed sacrament, reading classic literature, practicing Spanish, and improving her surfing skills.
This entry was posted in RC Live. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *